Murders by Women Differ from Those by Men

Nick Olivier • 22 June 2016

Each homicide has a unique fingerprint of circumstances and motive, from drugs and alcohol, to financial reasons, to the intangibles of jealousy and mental illness. No two killings are exactly the same. Men kill more often, according to innumerable studies. But now a study looks at a population of women who kill – and finds the fatal scenarios almost always play out right within the home, and between close members of the family. Twenty years of Swedish homicides became the focus of the study, published recently in the International Journal of Forensic Mental Health. The 1,570 homicides committed by a single killer were split, as usual, between the 90 percent by men, and the 10 percent perpetrated by women. But men were more likely to kill strangers and acquaintances in unfamiliar locations. Women, on the other hand, most often kill intimate partners or family members in their own homes, according to the Swedish researchers. “The adult victims of female perpetrators were more often male and an intimate partner,” said Thomas Nilsson, a researcher at Sahlgrenska Academy. “The victims were often under the influence of substances at the time of the crime and they died mostly due to knife violence.” Some 80 percent of the victims of women killers were family members. About 50 percent of homicides committed by females victimized intimate partners. And nine of 10 female killers took the victims’ lives in their own home. The females were more likely to live under ordered social conditions, and to have sought assistance from social services or police. Women were more likely to be classified as having a severe mental disorder at the time of their crimes – and their actions were more frequently classified as manslaughter or infanticide (women were more likely to kill children).
Men, on the other hand, had more charges and convictions of murder or involuntary manslaughter by assault. “These results taken together lend support to a quite common prototypical scenario, in which a habitually abusive man, disinhibited by intoxication, initiates a spiral of escalating aggression that culminates in him being killed by his female partner,” the authors write. Sweden has among the lowest per-capita homicide rates in the world. For instance, California has nearly as many annual homicides (approximately 1,600 – 1,700 per year) as the Scandinavian nation reported over the two decades of the study.

SOURCE:
ForensicMag

by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 9 May 2026
Editorial: (Fraud Risk Management) "A Comparison of Key Risk Management Frameworks: COSO-ERM, NIST RMF, ISO 31.000, COBIT."
by Nick Oliver (Ed.) 3 May 2026
Editorial: (Digital Forensics) "Digital Forensics Has a Body of Knowledge Problem. This Taxonomy Is My Attempt to Fix It."
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 2 May 2026
Editorial: (Forensic Science) Comparing "Thompson et al. 2025" with "Morrison et al. 2025": The Question About the Best Way to Present Likelihood Ratios.
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 24 April 2026
Editorial: (Forensic Science) "The Identification, Processing and Investigation of Forensic Investigative Leads in the South African Police Service"
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 23 April 2026
Editorial: (Investigative Interviewing) "Culture, Trauma, and Memory in Investigative Interviews"
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 22 April 2026
Editorial: (Law & Justice) "International Co-Operation in Criminal Matters in South Africa: A Comprehensive Analysis of Mutual Legal Assistance and Extradition"
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 21 April 2026
Editorial: (Forensic Pathology) "Forensic Maceration – A Comparative Analysis of Literature and Practical Application"
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 17 April 2026
Editorial: (Forensic Science) "Towards More Relevance in Forensic Science Research and Development"
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 15 April 2026
Editorial: (Forensic Science) "Artificial Intelligence in Forensic Science: Can It Be a Revolution or Else?"
by Nick Olivier (Ed.) 14 April 2026
Editorial: (Policing) "Bridging Policing Practice and Academic Excellence for Sustainable Crime Prevention and Public Sector Reform"